Online (Hungary) from 22 to 23 January 2021 in collaboration with UEF Hungary
On February 9, 2021, a court decision ruled that the Hungary’s National Media and Infocommunications Authority (NMHH) ‘s original decision to block the automatic extension of the talk and news station’s broadcast, Klubrádió licence was legal. Back in September 2020, the radio application for 92.2 frequency request was assessed unsuccessfully. At the basis of its unsuccessful application, its “unlawful” financial management and the fact that the programme package did not comply with the essential requirements of radio broadcasting. The mentioned NMHH, the body deciding about bid and tender of media frequency in Hungary is appointed and controlled by the ruling party Fidesz.
The media authority controlled by Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has been trying to take action against Klubrádió for years claiming fictitious violations of rules. The independent broadcasting station had been critical towards Orbán government in the past. According to the International Press Institute and the interview released by Andras Arató, Klubrádió Director, denounced two minor errors in the application documents, a radio show specified as 5 minutes shorter than its actual length and a program repetition. Furthermore, if the Media Council classified the radio financial situation as precarious and illegal, it did it aware of the fact that this precariousness is due to the governmental attempt to weaken independent media economic capacity.
Klubrádió stopped officially broadcasting on February 14th 2021, after 20 years. It is maintaining its activities, news reporting and talk radio programmes only through live-streaming online broadcasts.
The European institutions expressed several times their concerns on the Hungarian media freedom situation.
Several Members of the European Parliament spoke in favour of the independent media and the people affected by Orbán policies and political choices. In mid- February 2021, 80 Members of the European Parliament signed a letter to the European Commission and to the Council of the European Union urging them to take action against the restriction of press freedom in Hungary and Poland.
The European Commission widely criticized the Hungarian media laws and also released specific recommendations to overcome the excessive range of powers allocated to the Media Council. Last May the media law has been amended to enforce these powers, also limiting the courts’ possibility to review the Media Council decisions. On March 10, 2021, European Commission Vice President Vera Jourova addressed the latest worrying developments characterizing Hungary and media freedom, as well as Poland.
Christian Wigand, the European Commission spokesperson, in February, ensured that the Commission would assess the compatibility of the Hungarian court decision on the radio application against the EU laws and whether this has been respected while ruling the decision.
According to the Reporters Without Borders ‘s 2020 Freedom Index, Hungary ranks 89 on 189 countries.
Why we talk about Klubrádió? A Few days before our event about Hungary, organized with our partners on the field, UEF Hungary and JEF Hungary, UEF Hungary Secretary General, Eszter Nagy, Hungarian former Diplomat, presented the Democracy is Europe project and the related event on Hungary in a programme hosted by Klubrádió. For us, this was not only a way of disseminating information on our activities and events, but above all a way to support independent media in a country where they are facing restrictions and limitations.
Eszter Nagy summarised the situations follow:
“Klubrádió has been gradually deprived of its frequencies starting with the regional ones, until their last frequency has expired on February 14, 2021, and the Media Council hasn’t renewed it for them in spite of being the only applicant radio for this frequency. So, Klubrádió has been forced to the online sphere. They also face continuous financial difficulties due to the structure of the media advertising market: state companies tend not to advertise in independent media outlets, and even other businesses are afraid to do so fearing potential repercussions from the government. So Klubrádió decided to regularly conduct fundraising campaigns asking support from its listeners. Klubrádió has been the only radio with an independent news service, while all other radios use the news service provided by the Hungarian News Agency https://hirado.hu/rovatok/in-english/, a news agency fully dominated by the government.”
Click here to see the last moments of Hungarian broadcasting channel Klubrádió before switching to online modality.
Check out our first session, Democracy at the system change: a dream come true?